Ranger Tales
Once Free, Always Free

Once Free, Always Free

The story

Now hold on there, don't slip under that dome just yet. The name's Ranger Boone Merrick, and there's a tale here worth standing still for, right on the stone where you're at.

Put your eyes on those west doors. Plain steps, worn down soft by generations of feet. A man named Dred Scott climbed them. So did his wife, Harriet. And the question those two carried up these steps helped split a whole nation clean down the middle.

Dred Scott was brought to St. Louis a slave, back around eighteen thirty. In time he was owned by an Army doctor, John Emerson, and the Army moves a man around. Emerson carried Dred up into Illinois, a free state, and on to Fort Snelling, up in Wisconsin Territory, where slavery was barred by law. And it was up there, on free ground, that Dred met Harriet Robinson and married her. They had daughters.

Now here's the thing that matters. Missouri had an old rule on its books, once free, always free. The idea was plain enough: a slave taken to live on free soil came home a free person. And the Scotts had lived years on free soil. So in eighteen forty-six they walked into this courthouse and they filed suit. Not one suit, two. Dred filed his, and Harriet filed hers, right alongside, the only married couple anybody knows of to do it together. You remember her name. History near forgot it. Harriet Scott.

First trial, eighteen forty-seven, they lost. Lost on a technicality, a scrap of paperwork. Most folks would have walked away. The Scotts came back. Eighteen fifty, a St. Louis jury, sitting in this building, heard it all and set them free. Free. By the verdict of this very courtroom, Dred and Harriet Scott were free people.

It didn't hold. The Missouri Supreme Court reached down in eighteen fifty-two and took that freedom back. And the case kept climbing, out of this room, out of this city, all the way to the Supreme Court of the United States. March the sixth, eighteen fifty-seven. Chief Justice Roger Taney and his court ruled, seven to two, that a Black man was not a citizen, could not so much as bring a suit, and that Congress had no power to keep slavery out of the territories. It was about the worst decision that court ever handed down, and it poured lamp oil on a country already smoking toward civil war.

And here is the part that sits with me, friend. After all of it, after the highest court in the land had ruled against them, the family that once held the Scotts, the Blows, the very people Dred had grown up among, signed the papers and set Dred and Harriet free. May of eighteen fifty-seven. Just like that. By a stroke of a pen, they were handed the thing the whole machinery of the law had refused them.

Dred Scott had about sixteen months to taste it. Tuberculosis took him the next autumn. Harriet lived on, lived to see the war come and slavery end, the very thing those two had been reaching for on these steps.

So you stand here a moment. Won in this room. Lost in Washington. Freed at the end too late to do Dred much good, except it did everything. Next time somebody tells you one ordinary soul can't move a country, you come back to this stone and you think on a woman named Harriet Scott, who set her own name on a piece of paper and would not, for eleven long years, let it go.

Good to know
Where is Once Free, Always Free?
Once Free, Always Free. Now hold on there, don't slip under that dome just yet. The name's Ranger Boone Merrick, and there's a tale here worth standing still for, right on the stone where you're at. Put your eyes on those west doors. Plain ste…
Is there an audio tour of Once Free, Always Free?
Yes — Once Free, Always Free is a stop on the Gateway Arch National Park — The Myth and the Ledger self-guided audio tour. The story plays automatically by GPS as you walk there, and works offline. Get the Ranger Tales app on the App Store.
🎧 Get the tour

Hear Once Free, Always Free's story on the drive

Download the tour, leave your phone in your pocket, and let it play itself as you go. Works offline.